A must-have for any cat-eye lover, Paris-based Make Up For Ever’s Aqua Liner is one of the very best liquid eyeliners on the planet. Like all the cult-favorite professional brand’s formulas, the liners come in 15 high-pigment shades (iridescent navy to diamond multicolor black to fuchsia) and also provide waterproof staying power and the ultimate in precision thanks to an easily controlled ergonomic tip. $23